This is another pulp that I own
and read not long ago. Normally with pulps that I own, I try to use a cover
scan from the actual issue that I read, but I'm having problems with my scanner
so I had to get the image accompanying this post from the Fictionmags Index. The
cover is by H.W. Scott, who did so many covers for WESTERN STORY during this
era.
The lead novella is by Walt Coburn, who did some of his best work for WESTERN
STORY during this era. The protagonist of "Kavanaugh's Cattle Box" is
young cowboy Smoky Rutledge, who spends a year in Yuma Prison for a murder he
didn't commit. After being pardoned he returns to his home range to avenge his
father Keno, who is missing and thought to have been murdered by his former
partner Shane Kavanaugh, who now owns a ranch in a big box canyon on the
Arizona/Mexico border. The man Smoky supposedly killed was Pat Kavanaugh, Shane's son, but
it's possible he's still alive and hiding out below the border. Then there's Shane's outlaw
brother Bob and his son Jiggs, and Smoky's old friend, bronc buster Rusty
Britten, who now has a secret of his own, and the Spurlock cousins, Grant and
Tom. Not to mention beautiful redheaded cowgirl Chacha Kavanaugh, who either
loves Smoky Rutledge or hates him.
In many ways this is a prime example of a Walt Coburn story. There's so much
back-story and so many characters and plot twists coming at the reader so fast that
it's easy to get lost. But the whole mad whirl is spiced with cow country
authenticity and great over-the-top action scenes, and then by some miracle
Coburn ties everything together and it somehow makes sense. You can't really
analyze a Walt Coburn story. With the good ones, you just sit back and let it
carry you away and enjoy it. "Kavanaugh's Cattle Box" is a pretty
good one.
Moving on to the short stories, "The Battle at Bull Creek" is by Tom
W. Blackburn, one of the most dependable contributor to the Western pulps. This
"homesteaders and small rancher against evil cattle baron" yarn
really shows the influence of having been written during the early days of
World War II. There's a lot of talk about sticking together and standing up for
your neighbor. The thing is, I'm not sure if this angle was deliberate on
Blackburn's part or just a product of the times. It's a minor but decent story,
well-written as all of Blackburn's stories are.
Wayne D. Overholser is another long-time pulp author who went on to a sterling
career as a Western novelist. "Pasear to Death" is set in Oregon, as
many of Overholser's stories are, and finds the protagonist returning to the
town where he grew up to seek revenge on the man who killed his father and
brothers. The thing that sets this story a little apart from what you might
expect is that the hero is opposed to gunfighting and sets out to settle the
score in a different way. Overholser, like Blackburn, is a steady, dependable
author who usually entertains, and that's true here.
Archie Joscelyn wrote scores of stories for the pulps from the Twenties through
the Fifties but was probably better known for the many novels he wrote under
his own name, his primary pseudonym Al Cody, and a few other names. He doesn't
have much of a reputation anymore, but I've always enjoyed his work and have
read half a dozen of his novels that were excellent. His story is this issue of
WESTERN STORY is "Death on Parade", which finds Lieutenant Jim
Saunders assigned to find out what happened to a missing cavalry patrol.
Saunders' search, of course, leads him into danger and the middle of an outlaw
scheme. I'm not sure the plot completely makes sense, but the story has some
nice touches, including a sympathetic portrayal of some Indians who are
involved.
This issue also has an installment of a serial by Bennett Foster, "Man
Tracks", an animal story by Jim Kjelgaard, "Cougar Trail", and the
usual columns on guns, travel, and mining, plus the pen-pal column "The
Hollow Tree". It occurs to me that in this day and age some of you may not
be familiar with the concept of pen-pals. Think of it as Facebook that loads
really, really slowly.
Overall, this is a solid but unexceptional issue with enough good stories that
I'm glad I read it, if for no other reason than for Walt Coburn's distinctive
brand of Western storytelling.