Earlier this
summer, my daughter who teaches third grade was putting together a collection
of Newbery Award books for her classroom, and that put me in mind of this novel
by Emily Neville from 1964, which won the award that year for the most
distinguished contribution to American literature for children. 1964 or '65 is
when I read it, too, and I recalled liking it a great deal. So I decided to
reread it and see how it holds up more than fifty years later.
IT'S LIKE THIS, CAT is narrated by Dave Mitchell, a 14-year-old boy who lives
in Manhattan with his parents. This is the New York City you often see in sitcoms:
a little colorful in certain areas, maybe, but overall clean, charming, and safe.
Dave thinks nothing of going all over on his bike or taking subways, buses, and
ferries to all the boroughs. In a way, IT'S LIKE THIS, CAT is a bit of
travelogue, detailing the places Dave goes, the people he meets there, and the
things they do. He adopts Cat, a tomcat who comes to him from an eccentric
family friend. He meets a burglar who's not really a burglar. He has a falling
out with his best friend. He makes other friends and catches lizards in a park
with one of them. He meets a girl and begins a tentative romance with her. It's
all very episodic, and Cat, even though he's in the title of the book, seems to
disappear for long stretches of it.
Neville writes very well, especially about the city. This particular version of
New York may be a fantasy, but she makes it an appealing, gently humorous one.
Dave is a likable, realistic protagonist, and his relationship with the girl he
meets at Coney Island is handled in a believable fashion. The plot is
realistic, too, in that it just sort of meanders along, never really comes to
any sort of point, and then stops abruptly, which is just like life, I guess. I
have to admit, this may be one of those books where I was better off
remembering it fondly rather than revisiting it. However, I think IT'S LIKE
THIS, CAT is worth reading if you haven't read it before, because it does a
good job of evoking a particular time. It's a nice book. Sometimes that's what you want to read.