This is a pulp that I own and read recently. My copy isn’t in the greatest shape, but that’s it in the scan, featuring a nice, evocative cover by Clarence Doore. You can feel the sweltering heat just looking at it, can’t you? One oddity of note is that it’s 5 WESTERN NOVELS MAGAZINE on the cover and the masthead on the title page, but FIVE WESTERN NOVELS MAGAZINE on the spine, the indicia, and the page headers. I’m going to make the arbitrary decision to use the version with the number when I refer to it in this post.
Calling this 5 WESTERN NOVELS MAGAZINE was something of an exaggeration, of
course. The contents actually consist of three novellas, two novelettes, and a
bonus short story. This title was, for the most part, a reprint pulp. There’s
only one original story in this issue, and that’s the novella that leads things
off, “Pistol Partners” by Lee Floren.
Now, Lee Floren has never been one of my favorite Western authors, but I’m
coming to enjoy his work more over time. Also, this story features his
longest-running series characters, Buckshot McKee and Tortilla Joe, a couple of
drifting cowpokes who always manage to wind up in the middle of dangerous situations
and sinister mysteries. I’ve read several novels starring Buck and Joe and
enjoyed them. In “Pistol Partners”, they’ve come to New Mexico to answer a call
for help from an old friend who is sick and has to go to the hospital. He wants
Buck and Joe to take care of his pet cat for him.
That cat turns out to be a tame mountain lion named Madagascar Jones. The “hospital”
in which the old friend is holed up is a boarding house run by a beautiful
former madam, and all the boarders are beautiful saloon girls, one of whom is
the unlikely bride of the old codger who summoned Buck and Joe. A ruthless cattle
baron wants the old-timer’s land, several men have been killed, supposedly by
the mountain lion Madagascar Jones, and Buck and Joe get shot at several times.
This is the goofiest Lee Floren story I’ve read, rivaling W.C. Tuttle’s Sheriff
Henry yarns in places. But it’s also full of action, well-plotted, and a lot of
fun. There are a few examples of the slapdash writing common in Floren’s work—a
guy rides up on horseback, for example, and in the very next paragraph he came
up on foot and his horse is hidden in the brush—but if you can forgive that,
and I can, “Pistol Partners” is pretty darned enjoyable.
William Hopson’s novelette “Trail Drive Boss” first appeared in the September
1945 issue of POPULAR WESTERN. As you can tell from the title, it’s a trail
drive yarn in which a young cattleman butts heads with a crooked town boss who
controls the only water in the area and uses exorbitant prices to steal herds.
There’s also a beautiful woman involved, of course, and not everything is as it
seems at first. Hopson was inconsistent but mostly very good, and this is an
excellent tale that I enjoyed.
“Sixgun Sweepstakes”, a novella by Walker A. Tompkins, is a reprint from the June
1948 issue of POPULAR WESTERN. Tompkins is a long-time favorite of mine, and he
doesn’t disappoint in this story about a town-taming lawman from Texas who’s
the marshal of a town in Washington state. He throws in an intriguing angle
about the friction between ranchers and wheat farmers but never really does
anything with that plot element. Instead, this is a Fourth of July story with a
rodeo and a big celebration highlighted by a stagecoach race. One of the
marshal’s old enemies shows up in town before the shindig begins, and the
romantic triangle between the two of them and the beautiful daughter of a state
senator complicates matters before the villain’s true plan is revealed.
Tompkins is in good form in this story. There’s plenty of action, a fight on a
train, the stagecoach race, and a few plot twists. It would have been better if
the fight had been on top of the train (anybody who’s read much of my work
knows I love those scenes), and a running shootout during the stagecoach race
would have been nice. But that’s just me. “Sixgun Sweepstakes” is a solid yarn
that would have made a good 1950s Western movie.
The novella “Dead Man’s Gold” by Larry A. Harris first appeared in the June 1948
issue of THRILLING WESTERN. A young man’s search for a fortune in gold supposedly
hidden by his crazy uncle in the Devil’s River country of Texas puts him in conflict
with a crooked banker and a corrupt lawman. The story moves right along and
there’s plenty of action, but the writing is pretty flat and bland and the
protagonist is so stupid that it stretches the reader’s willing suspension of
disbelief too far. He does one dumb thing after another just to keep the plot
going. Harris wrote hundreds of stories for the pulps but only a few novels, all
of them featuring the Masked Rider. One of those was reprinted in paperback,
Harris’s only book publication that I know of. I’ve read a few things by him in
the past and found them okay at best. This one is a clear misfire.
The short story “Reunion at Amigo” is by veteran Western writer Allan K. Echols
and originally appeared in the June 1948 issue of MASKED RIDER WESTERN. It’s
about an old outlaw who has escaped from prison and is searching for his son.
It’s pretty well-written overall, but the final twist is so obvious that it
detracts quite a bit from the story’s appeal.
This issue wraps up with “The Necktie Party”, a novelette by Malcolm
Wheeler-Nicholson from the July 1948 issue of EXCITING WESTERN. At first
glance, this is a cavalry vs. the Apaches yarn, but as it turns out, there’s
more to it than that as a young lieutenant tries to save a civilian scout from
being lynched, prevent a new Indian war, and round up the bad guys, all at the
same time. As always, Wheeler-Nicholson brings an undeniable air of authenticity
to a story with a military background. This is an enjoyable tale weakened by an
ending that’s not very dramatic and resolves things too easily.
As far as I remember, this is the first issue of 5 WESTERN NOVELS MAGAZINE, so
I don’t have any basis to compare and say how it stacks up against the others
in the series. Just as a Western pulp, though, I think it’s a little below
average. I was surprised at how good the Floren story is, and there’s nothing
wrong with the Hopson tale, but the entries by Tompkins, Wheeler-Nicholson, and
Echols were good but could have been better, and the one by Harris just isn’t
very good. I really like the cover by Clarence Doore, though. Overall, probably
worth reading, but don’t rush to your shelves to see if you have a copy.
No comments:
Post a Comment