
I've mentioned before that I prefer Elmore Leonard's
Westerns to his crime novels, which puts me in the minority, I'm sure. Not that
that bothers me. I've read all of Leonard's Western short stories and am
working my way slowly through his Western novels.
Originally published in 1956, ESCAPE FROM FIVE SHADOWS is Leonard's third
novel. It opens where a lot of novels might end: with the unjustly convicted
protagonist's escape from prison. Corey Bowen, found guilty of rustling and
sent to Yuma Prison, then to the work camp called Five Shadows, doesn't get
away, though. He's recaptured and brought back, and that's just the beginning
of a tense, low-key story that includes plenty of suspense and just enough
action and romance.
As you'd expect from a novel by Elmore Leonard, even an early one, the dialogue
is excellent and most of the characters can't be trusted as they play off of
each other and try to gain an advantage. In addition to Corey Bowen, there are
a couple of other inmates who are part of a second escape plan with him; the
corrupt superintendent of the prison camp; a government official and his femme
fatale wife; the beautiful daughter of a stagecoach station manager; and the
Apache trackers whose job it is to go after prisoners who try to get away.
ESCAPE FROM FIVE SHADOWS is a slow burn of a novel that finally erupts in some
excellent action scenes. As usual, Leonard's depiction of Arizona Territory is
excellent, with the landscape almost becoming a character in its own right. If
you've never read any of his Western novels, this would be a fine place to
start.
