Sometimes a book takes you completely by surprise. That’s
the case with NIGHTRIDER DEPUTY. Ralph R. Perry was a fairly successful pulp
author for three decades, from the mid-Twenties to the mid-Fifties, turning out
scores of Western, mystery, aviation, and sea stories. As far as I know,
NIGHTRIDER DEPUTY is his only novel. It was published in 1954 as half of Ace
Double D-72 along with Norman A. Fox’s THE DEVIL’S SADDLE and has never been
reprinted. If I’ve ever read any of Perry’s pulp stories, they didn’t impress
me enough for me to remember them, so when I started this book I was hoping for
nothing more than a competently written Western.
Turns out it’s a lot more than that.
Oh, the plot is traditional enough. Young Mat Karney returns to the Toltec
Valley, where he’s inherited his father’s ranch. He finds that homesteaders are
moving in, along with small ranchers who threaten the big spreads belonging to
Mat and his chief competitor, Big Tom Parks. There’s some rustling going on,
too, and Mat suspects Parks may be behind it. What really sets everything in
motion, though, is when the train Mat is taking back to the valley is stopped
and robbed, and a homesteader on the train is killed during the holdup.
“The man was already dead, yet the girl pressed the compress on the wound as
though by sheer will she could push life back into the body.”
I read that and thought, “That’s a pretty good line.” Not Hemingway, maybe, but
not bad. It’s on the third page of the book, and as I continued reading I
enjoyed Perry’s distinctive, hardboiled style. Then the plot twists kicked in.
Yeah, this is a range war book, but instead of the usual two factions, there
are half a dozen, and the alliances between them are constantly shifting until
you can’t be sure who’s really on whose side. Several overlapping romantic
triangles complicate things even more, and this is one case where I wasn’t sure
which girl the hero was going to wind up with, or even which one he should wind up with. Characters you
don’t expect to die don’t make it to the end of the book. There are some really
suspenseful scenes and some epic shootouts, climaxing with a very satisfying
battle.
The title NIGHTRIDER DEPUTY doesn’t really fit the book, which makes me suspect
some editor slapped it on the manuscript. The generic title and the rather
bland cover (the scan is from the copy I read, as usual, beat up though it may
be) lead the reader to expect a very run-of-the-mill Western. Instead, while it
doesn’t quite rise to classic level, NIGHTRIDER DEPUTY is a really fine Western
novel. It’s also the best book I’ve read so far this year, and I’ll definitely
be looking to read more of Ralph R. Perry’s work.
(Note: Since this is Perry's only novel that I know of, I suppose technically it's his first novel, too, which fits today's Forgotten Books theme, but I wasn't thinking of that when I wrote and scheduled this post.)