Reading Mearle Prout’s “The House of the Worm” the other day put me in the mood to read more like that, so I dug out my copy of the S.T. Joshi-edited anthology A MOUNTAIN WALKED: GREAT TALES OF THE CTHULHU MYTHOS and read “Far Below” by Robert Barbour Johnson, which appeared originally in the June/July 1939 issue of WEIRD TALES.
In Joshi’s introduction, he says that in 1953, readers of WEIRD TALES voted “Far Below” as the best story ever published in the magazine. Well, no, not hardly, in my opinion, for reasons I’ll get to. But it is a very good story in some ways.
The whole thing is some nameless narrator who’s a writer talking to a friend of his, a former doctor and scientist, in some sort of bizarre control room buried deep below the streets of New York in the subway system. It seems that, unknown to the general public, monsters roam through a certain section of the subway in the middle of the night, and the New York Police Department has set up special squads and listening posts (of which this is one) to monitor their activities and protect the subway riders from them.
That’s a great concept, and as the doctor-turned-cop explains all the background to his friend, there are some wonderfully creepy bits, so vivid that they linger in the mind. But when you get right down to it, other than a little twist at the end, that’s all “Far Below” is: a concept. Very well written, to be sure, but nothing happens. That’s why it’s far from the best story ever published in WEIRD TALES as far as I’m concerned.
But am I glad that I read it? Absolutely! As I said, it’s very well-written, and I enjoy being creeped out from time to time. This’ll do it, that’s for sure. You can find used copies of A MOUNTAIN WALKED on-line, but they’re pretty pricey. Or you can hunt up a PDF of that issue of WEIRD TALES. Either way, I recommend “Far Below”, and I figure I might just delve a little deeper into the Mythos this week.



3 comments:
One thing not mentioned in the review is that the story may have been inspired by one of the pictures described in the H. P. Lovecraft story "Pickman's Model". There also exists at least one reading of the story on the Horror Babble youtube channel that is worth listening to.
I didn't know about the "Pickman's Model" connection. Thanks for pointing it out. I don't think I've ever read "Pickman's Model", although I seem to recall reading a comics adaptation of it in one of Marvel's horror titles many, many years ago. I don't remember anything about the story itself, though, so I ought to read it.
I would recommend reading "Pickman's Model", it's one of H. P. Lovecraft's less mythos heavy stories. Again there are quite a few good readings of the story out there. The story also gets name checked in the British detective series 'Endeavour'. If I remember it correctly they started throwing in Lovecraftian name drops for several seasons, it was mostly things like having characters come from Kingsport, Massachusetts and the like but supposedly there is a reference to Richard Upton Pickton and "Pickman's Model', in this case a person rather than what's revealed in the climax of the Lovecraft story.
Post a Comment