
My general dislike of H.P. Lovecraft's work, while still
acknowledging its influence and historical significance in the field of Weird
Fiction, has gotten me in trouble on more than one occasion in the past. But
for some reason, every so often I get the urge to read something by him, maybe in
the hope of finding a story that I like. And whaddaya know, I finally did.
I'm fudging a little with this week's entry. "Herbert West:
Reanimator" is a novella, not a novel, but it's been published by itself
enough times that I think I can count it as a book. Nor is it really forgotten,
since it's readily available in any number of print and digital editions.
However, if Jeff Shanks hadn't included it in his recent anthology ZOMBIES FROM
THE PULPS!, I probably never would have read it, so it was pretty close to
being forgotten where I was concerned.
All the things I find annoying about Lovecraft's work are present here: the
long-winded prose (although this one does seem to move along at a little faster
clip that the other stories I've read by him), the scarcity of dialogue, the
overall wussiness of the protagonists. But the genuine creepiness of this tale
of a doctor who tries to discover the secret of reanimating dead bodies won me
over. It's episodic, reflecting its origins as a serial in a literary magazine
in 1922, but that works for me since it serves to pick up the pace. (The
novella was reprinted in WEIRD TALES in 1942, after Lovecraft's death.) There
are even several instances of violent action that work pretty well.
So, being curious how other people feel about this story since I liked it, I
went on-line and discovered that Lovecraft himself reportedly hated it.
Lovecraft scholar S.T. Joshi says that it's universally reviled as Lovecraft's
worst story. Somehow this does not surprise me. It figures that the one I like,
many of his fans hate. But as usual, I don't care. It's the most pulpish
Lovecraft story I've read so far, which is a good thing as far as I'm concerned.
And it's got me interested enough to read something else by Lovecraft in the
relatively near future. If anybody wants to recommend anything in the comments,
based on my comments on this one, have at it. I'd appreciate the input.
I'll have more to say about ZOMBIES FROM THE PULPS! in due course. It'll
probably take me a while to read it, since I tend to work in stories from
anthologies between novels, but for me it's off to a good start with
"Herbert West: Reanimator". (Side note: I've never seen the movies
based on this story, which supposedly don't share much with it other than the
title. I'd watch a faithful movie adaptation of it, though.)